A while ago I reviewed the original L'Oreal Miss Manga mascara, {click here to read the review.} Recently L'Oreal came out with the Miss Manga Rock mascara, and I thought it would be great to review it and almost compare it to the original one. I've been testing it longer than I do for other products, since this review is also a comparison. I'm excited to share what I found with you guys. So let's start~~!
Like the original, I love the cute packaging. It's the same design, except instead of pink and black as the color scheme, it is yellow and black. I just wish the cute little chibi faces were on the mascara tube, cause I think the tube is boring.
This mascara promises to create overloaded lashes, meaning it should volumized them, on both the top and bottom lashes, as well as separate them. I have been testing it out for a few weeks now, and I can say it does both of those things, but not the the extent it is advertised.
The wand is different the the original Miss Manga, which is a wire brush. The Miss Manga Rock wand is plastic with short spikes. Also unlike the Miss Manga, the Miss Manga Rock isn't as flimsy or bendy.
Here's a before and after, on the left is mascara and on the right is no mascara. This mascara definitely lengthens, but I have used more volumizing mascaras, both high-end and from the drugstore.
Here's a comparison of the Miss Manga and Miss Manga Rock. On the left is the Miss Manga Rock and on the right is original Miss Manga.
I like how both of them look, but I can't choose a favorite. I like Miss Manga because it really lengthens my lashes and makes them look light and fluttery. I like Miss Manga Rock because it lengthens and thickens my lashes.
I actually got this as part of a birthday gift from one of my friends, so I didn't buy this. In my local drugstores, it costs $7.99, which is normal for a drugstore mascara. I do like this mascara enough that I would repurchase it for that price.
Packaging: ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♡
Formula: ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
Wand: ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
Price: ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
Overall: ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♡
I really like this mascara. It does lengthen and lightly volumizes my lashes. I do wish it was more volumizing, because I've used other mascaras that are more volumizing. Other than that I think it's a really great mascara. I can use it on my bottom lashes, which is great, because usually I use two different mascaras for top and bottom lashes.
I hope you guys enjoyed today's review~! If you have tried this mascara, let me know your opinions on it in the comments below. Also I recently posted a video on my YouTube channel, and I'd love it if you checked it out, {click here} to watch it. Thank you guys so much for reading and I'll see you at my next post.
xo
Alyss
This mascara looks awesome. Great review dear. :-)
ReplyDeletehttp://naturelbellefemme.blogspot.com
wow, looks nice, thanks for the recomendation :D Nice review.
ReplyDeleteBoth of them look really good!! I think its super awesome that you showed us how each product worked side by side. Based of this, I think id favor the original :) Followed you on bloglovin <3 Hope you check my blog out (and maybe even follow back)
ReplyDeleteBCfactor.blogspot.com
Hi, dear!
ReplyDeleteThank you for visiting my blog <3
I love your posts! And I also love anime)
What about mutual following? Please answer me on my blog ))
kireikana.blogspot.com
Thank you for stopping by on my blog :) Your review is really nice and I've been thinking for quite a while if I should try that mascara or not~ maybe I'll just give it a try :)
ReplyDeletexoxo, Merce
www.its-mercedita.blogspot.de
thanks for the mascara review is so great
ReplyDeletexoxoxoxoxoxo
http://knowledgeandhappiness.blogspot.com/
Both look great on your lashes! I tend to prefer the Punky one as I find the wand on the original a little bit wobbly! xx
ReplyDeleteJasmine Talks Beauty